Emphasis on care, respect and renewal
My name is Becky Pilon, and I am the spa manager at Lightwater Cove. I am also a proud member of the Michipicoten First Nation. I am writing in response to last week’s Driftwood article about Lightwater Cove. I would like to share a personal perspective on what Lightwater Cove truly represents.
I have known the owners Monika and Greg Phillips for four years, and in that time I have seen firsthand the dedication, care and respect they bring to their stewardship of Lightwater Cove. First and foremost, Lightwater Cove is a working farm. The farm stand provides fresh food to the community, and the majority of the employees here are farmers, gardeners and landscapers who devote their work to maintaining and nurturing the land. This farm identity is at the heart of Lightwater Cove, and it will continue to be a farm and continue to operate in this way for years to come.
Alongside its farming roots, the property includes botanical gardens, orchards and its ongoing efforts with individuals like Sequoia honour native plants and ecosystems. Through hosting groups, Monika and Greg have welcomed meaningful conversations and knowledge-sharing, including with the K’ómoks First Nation and the Tsawout First Nation, as well as with community members seeking to learn and grow together in relationship with the land.
On a personal note, Monika and Greg have not only kept me employed but have also contributed to my livelihood and stability, as they have for many others in the community. Their ongoing support of local employment and businesses is significant and should not be overlooked.
It was disappointing to see that the Driftwood did not reach out to Monika or Greg for comment before publishing such a serious article. Offering them an opportunity to share their perspective would have brought balance and fairness, which I believe is an important part of professional reporting.
For me, and for many others, Lightwater Cove is a place of care, respect and renewal. It honours Salt Spring’s legacy of farming and gardening, fosters meaningful work and creates space for shared experiences that connect people more deeply with the land and with each other.
Becky Pilon, Spa manager, Lightwater Cove, Salt Spring
Trust should reconsider approach
I was disheartened to read of the legal proceedings brought against Lightwater Cove by the Islands Trust regarding alleged non-compliance with land use requirements.
From my perspective, the owners have treated this property with great care and respect, transforming it into a beautiful place which nurtures the land and its visitors.
The vast majority of the property is dedicated to gardens and orchards, employing local gardeners and landscapers. The home highlights craftsmanship of local artisans, and the property is a place where community and stewardship are actively practised. There is the luxury bed-and-breakfast style offering, but it is primarily operated as a farm and land-based business that reflects deep respect for the coastline and surrounding environment.
I sincerely hope the Islands Trust will reconsider its approach and acknowledge the value of this well-kept, community-minded property — a place that reflects the very spirit of care and sustainability that our island strives to uphold.
Hannah Mazza, Salt Spring
Port Angeles corner an inspiration
Not long after walking off the Black Ball Ferry in Port Angeles, Wash., you come to a corner that is the best welcome to any town. A fabulous open building greets you. Basically it’s a large roof on posts. Flowerbeds surround the square.
The junction of the two roads reminds me of the way you enter Ganges coming from Fulford-Ganges Road — the first glimpse you get coming into Ganges.
This covered junction in Port Angeles is host to the farmers’ market, art markets, music events and much more.
When our old firehall needs to be repurposed, I hope the clock tower, in characteristic red and white, could remain. It can be the central point of a covered square very similar to the one in Port Angeles. The area could serve as an overflow Saturday Market, offer space to Saturday and Tuesday market vendors and entice locals and tourists alike to sit, lick an ice cream cone and enjoy a central meeting point across from the park. It could even house our tourism office and serve as an open air art gallery for local visual artists.
I hope our Local Community Commission, Islands Trust, Chamber of Commerce and any other powers-that-be will consider using Port Angeles’ market as an example of a relatively easy way to remake our firehall area into a welcoming, pedestrian-friendly square while preserving our local heritage.
Margriet Ruurs, Salt Spring
Cove zoning solution offered
I was seething with outrage after reading last week’s Driftwood. Flinging the paper at the cat, I took to the keyboard, determined to raise hell in defence of the island’s beleaguered small farming community.
The heavy-handed Islands Trust has launched legal action against Lightwater Cove for alleged minor infractions of zoning regulations. The subtle difference in definition between “agriculture” and “full-on luxury resort” leaves the issue open to interpretation. Some critics feel that “Salt Spring Eco Lodging Company Ltd.” failed to ensure that their mallards and Muscovies were in alignment before shovelling cash into the dude ranch, but who could possibly have seen this coming?
As the owners claim, the oceanfront guest house rentals, spa, sauna, swimming pool, etc. are “secondary” to the farming activities and the revenue generated by each of these endeavours will remove all doubt. Obviously the investment involved in the construction of that rustic farmhouse pictured on page 3 of the paper will be recovered with farmstand sales in a very short time, but passing off wealthy guests as migrant farm labourers could prove challenging. As always, I have the solution!
Visitors vacationing at the cove will self identify as “livestock”and stay in very comfortable “barns.” When the Islands Trust Zoning Swat Team raids the place, those guests wandering around outside will say “moo”or “baa”or “oink,” while those in the hot tub will utter “quack quack” while flapping their arms. I see no reason for this plan to be anything other than a roaring success, but in the unlikely case that the Trust sees through the charade, Lightwater Cove can always be upgraded to the standards required for a homeless shelter. No need to thank me; just glad I could help.
MIKE STACEY, SALT SPRING
Proud of icon
I stand with Neil Young’s new song called Big Crime. It directly points a finger at the growing fascist regime to the south of us.
I am proud of this Canadian icon for his bravery in speaking the truth in an ever-increasing climate of fear and intimidation. And more of us need to speak out.
You can see the video on Neil Young’s website.
Bodhi Sturrey, Salt Spring
Participate in Trust process
I want to express an opinion about participating in a democracy: it’s important to join in.
We are watching the world change. Fewer and fewer people are allowed to take part in government, plus fewer and fewer people actually take advantage when they are allowed.
We have the chance to voice our opinions about the Islands Trust Policy Statement. There is the chance to participate in a Zoom meeting tonight (Sept.10) — call (250-537-9144 or go to the islandstrust.bc.ca website to register) — paper copies of the draft document are at the library, or you can read it on the Trust website.
Feedback can also be shared through the online survey, by email at islands2050@islandstrust.bc.ca, by phone at 250-405-5151, or directly with your Islands Trust trustees.
Personally, I want the trustees to know exactly what I care about and what I want them to preserve and protect. I will be letting them know. I urge you to do the same.
Debbie Magnusson, Salt Spring
See full picture
I read your recent article regarding Lightwater Cove with concern, and I feel it’s important to add another perspective.
While the lawsuit focuses on the property through the lens of bylaws and zoning, what I have personally witnessed at Lightwater Cove tells a very different story. The most striking thing is the environmental stewardship. Native plants have been reintroduced, natural water flows restored and in turn many plant species that had disappeared from the area are returning. These are not claims made for publicity. I have seen these changes with my own eyes.
The scale of ecological renewal that has taken place there is significant. The land is healthier now than it has been in decades, and that is the direct result of long-term care, investment and respect for the island’s natural systems.
As for the concern over “resort operations,” from my perspective the actual impact on the environment and surrounding community has been minimal, especially when weighed against the environmental benefits that are already evident. What stands out most is not commercialization, but restoration.
I believe our community deserves to see this full picture: alongside the legal dispute there is a genuine, sustained effort to heal and steward land that is part of Salt Spring’s heritage. That effort should matter in how we understand and talk about Lightwater Cove.
Jordan Ettinger, Salt Spring
Black likes Trump
In reply to Paul McElroy’s latest column, “Assault on Democracy Unfolding to the South Impossible to Ignore,” I offer the last two paragraphs of the latest Conrad Black column in the Sept. 6 National Post:
“Trump has prevailed against overwhelming media opposition, was heavily outspent in last year’s election, faced utterly spurious indictments, and was even given insufficient security protection against potential assassins in his campaign. He is widely portrayed as a boob and a gangster but in his career prior to being inaugurated president, as a quality builder and developer, immense reality television star, and innovative political strategist, he achieved more than any president except those vital to the founding of the country (Washington, Jefferson, Madison), and the victorious commanders of great armies in just wars, (Grant, Eisenhower), and possibly Herbert Hoover for his administration of relief to war-ravaged Europe after World War I. In 2016 he saw a level of public discontent that no one else recognized and became the first person elected president of the U.S., never to have sought or held any public office or high military command.
“No one has ever been so severely and illegally obstructed as president and as a presidential candidate as he has, and he has become a considerable president in reorienting the country club Republican Party of the Bushes, McCain and Romney, to crack the Democratic fiefdoms of working class and ethnic minority votes, and in producing and broadening prosperity, shaping up the Western Alliance, ending the invasion of the United States by illegal immigrants, attacking the forces of wokeness in the universities, forcefully reducing crime rates, drastically reducing the fiscal and trade deficits, attracting in seven months nearly $15 trillion of new investment to the United States, destroying the Iranian nuclear military program and evicting men from girls’ sports and requiring mature approvals of trans-gender changes. This will not be undone by venomous and ignorant piffle from the media, especially the Trump-deranged and chronically bigoted Canadian media.”
William Steiner, Salt Spring