Wednesday, June 12, 2024
June 12, 2024

Viewpoint: Let’s restore the public square


When the Fulford Inn closed in 2010, I did not see myself assuming ownership of the property. Far from it.

Something changed for me as the years of inaction passed by. I suppose I could say I lived nearby and would drive by it often, watching the impacts. I suppose I could say it was the murder of Joseph Birney in that area, or the noticeable decline of Fulford village life, or just the absence of a place that had a heartbeat and vibrancy that I was familiar with. I honestly don’t really know. In time, by about 2015 or so, however, I came to the view that the decline of the Fulford Inn was the loss of an essential gathering and meeting place to our community.

We may each of us feel tangible personal grief when considering the challenges our community faces — climate change, habitat loss, fishery decline, homelessness, income inequality, drug addiction — but these horsemen have always been lurking. No simple decision or plan will emerge which solves any of these problems. The only way we can meet the challenges of the future is to build and strengthen our community life, our connection and obligation to each other. We cannot defeat these horsemen, only face them, and that will be easier if we do it together.

Albert Camus wrote: “All great deeds and great thoughts had a ridiculous beginning. Great works are often born on a street corner or a restaurant’s revolving door.” This is the public square: the place where we gather and engage in a sharing of viewpoints, backgrounds and abilities. It is in the public square that ideas and opinions clash and wrestle and give rise to innovation, enterprise and opportunity. Literally and figuratively we inhabit a world today without a public square; it has been privatized “online” and called “speech.” Largely fuelled by division, drama and conflict, this private square is so antithetical to our shared history that we find ourselves in a world where complexity and intellect are frequently outmatched by emotion.

Much as it may feel better to hang on to a simple principle and hold true to that belief through to the bitter end, in the real world we must measure and weigh the practical benefits and costs and determine the best path forward on the basis of many outcomes. This does not come without often difficult compromise.

Much has been written of late in this newspaper regarding the Vortex project and the various reasons why the proposal should be denied by the Local Trust Committee. I share all of the concerns of the authors and I support their important voices for our island. Instead of debating, I hope to build understanding. For that purpose I created an easy-to-navigate website ( to provide access to the technical information, design rationale, and various design plans that make up the basis of the application. I hope people will visit the website for themselves and inform their understanding of the proposal. While the Islands Trust hold the bar for development high, a view of the website will illustrate that we have well exceeded that bar.

As always, I thank the many neighbours and friends who have supported our efforts during this long campaign to rebuild the Fulford Inn. I look forward to the final decision and moving one step toward realizing the goal of reestablishing a community gathering space and public square at Fulford Harbour.

Sign up for our newsletter and stay informed

Receive news headlines every week with our free email newsletter.

Other stories you might like

‘Estuary’ project to proceed without water district 

A commercial project at Fulford now plans to draw and treat its own water after “impossible” requests from the water district there, according to...

Developers ask to join Fulford Water System

Planners for a new development at the site of the former Fulford Inn are asking Fulford Water System (FWS) commission members to recommend the...

Opinion: Fulford water report raises serious concerns

By JOHN MILLSON and JEAN WILKINSON For SSI Water Preservation Society board The Salt Spring Island Water Preservation society is a charitable organization that has been...

CRD director responds to Fulford Water Service Commissioners

BY GARY HOLMAN SALT SPRING CRD DIRECTOR At their April 14 meeting, Fulford Water Service commissioners vented their frustrations about CRD. Unfortunately, the commission didn’t come...


  1. Despite the letters that have been decrying the Vortex development in Fulford, there are many islanders who are eager to see this innovative solution move forward and bring some positive energy to what has been a pit of despair and dereliction for more than a decade.
    The Vortex is to be located at the site of the original Fulford Inn, which provided food and accommodations for generations of Saltspringers in the south end. The Vortex will continue in that tradition and provide a much-needed gathering place and local guest accommodations. Having a local facility avoids the environmental and safety problems of people driving all the way to Ganges or running the gauntlet into Fulford village to find a restaurant or accommodation.
    The old Fulford Inn also hosted local groups and friends who met there regularly. The local Saltspringer behind the Vortex project says he wants to recreate that energy by providing a location that brings people together and improves the environmental mess that was left behind by the old inn. Will the Vortex be the Fulford Inn? No, but the Vortex is a local, innovative, on-island solution if ever there was one.
    Some opponents of the project would like to see the area turned into a park. However, they fail to see that property has already been purchased! Creating a park would require the owner being willing to sell the property and park advocates being able to raise sufficient funds to purchase it before someone else – off island – buys it first.
    In the interest of fairness, the local Saltspringer who took the time and risk to purchase the site deserves the chance to implement their vision for it. Voting down the proposed Vortex at this late stage is unfair, stifles other innovative ideas, and results in community cynicism and stagnation
    Lastly, voting down the proposal will not magically improve the situation for many years, if at all. It will simply prolong the blight of a toxic eyesore that greets visitors and residents alike to the island.
    Let’s not let a vision of perfection get in the way of a positive, concrete plan out of the current weeds…

    • Thankyou Dave Rumsby!! Let’s hope the Vortex project comes to pass. So many of the fine folks in the Fulford area fully support it. Lord knows we could use all what the Vortex has to offer. In this day and age we can develop a project like this and still be aware of our fragile environment and and put the safeguards in place to protect it. The folks planning this project are absolutely wonderful people. We are lucky to have them living on SSI. Let’s face it! Saltspring needs the new life and energy. It’s been a long journey and something this positive will bring us together as a community.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here